Macdonald Holyrood Hotel, Edinburgh

81 Holyrood Rd, Edinburgh, EH8 8AU 4

Das Macdonald Holyrood Hotel ist ein modernes Hotel im Zentrum von Edinburgh, in unmittelbarer Nähe des Schottischen Parlaments, Edinburgh Castles und der Ausst... more

Einchecken:
Auschecken:
 

£ Zimmer ab £ 95 (≈ $174) pro Nacht
Zur Anzeige verfügbarer Hotels bitte Datum eingeben

8/10 Gesamtbewertung

Kategorie Durchschnittsbewertung
9/10 Das Check-in Verfahren
8/10 Ihr Zimmer
8/10 Die Betriebsfähigkeit der Einrichtungen/Ausrüstungen
9/10 Die Ordung und Sauberkeit des Hotels
9/10 Die Leistung des Personals
9/10 Ihr allgemeiner Erfahrungswert
9/10 Würden Sie ihr Hotel als allgemein Preiswert einstufen?
  • 8/10 Alexander ( Familie mit älteren Kindern) 

    aus Zug , Switzerland  am  4. November 2004

    "Neueres Hotel mit schönen Zimmern. Zentrale Lage in der Altstadt, guter Service. Internetbuchung sehr schnell." (1604035)

    Zentral gelegen. Freundliche Angestellte.

    Keine.

    1 von 1 Personen fanden diese Gästebewertung hilfreich:

  • 9/10 Anonymous ( Alleinreisender in geschäftlicher Angelengenheit) 

    am  14. Juni 2007

    Excellent location, friendly and helpful staff

    Air conditioning broken and not fixed during stay

    1 von 1 Personen fanden diese Gästebewertung hilfreich:

  • 9/10 Beryl ( Gruppe von Arbeitskollegen) 

    aus Gateshead , GB  am  27. August 2008

    "Excellent thank you." (108009744)

    Very very comfortable. Would stay here again and recommend it to friends

  • 9/10 Anonymous ( Reiferes Paar) 

    am  5. Juni 2007

    "The location was at the end of the Royal Mile, in a quiet scenic area, and within easy walking distance of many shops (mostly tartan kilts and scarves etc) and bars of the 'old town'. It was just a stonesthrow away from the Scottish Parliament, Holyrood Palace. Mother Earth and Holyrood Park. The 'new town'(all the modern high street shops) was a little further away with a hilly 15/20 min walk, but there were usually taxis across the road." (99316833)

    The food was nice and good quality. The pool was big enough. The staff were mostlt pleasant and helpful.

    The evening meal service was slow (3 courses). Drinks were quite expensive.

    1 von 1 Personen fanden diese Gästebewertung hilfreich:

  • 7/10 Helen ( Junges Paar) 

    aus Sheffield , GB  am  31. Juli 2008

    "Pleasant modern hotel, good location, for the price of the room (pretty expensive), expected to be faultless but wallpaper ripped on wall and marks on the carpet - disappointing." (107114187)

    Modern clean hotel, friendly staff, great location as we were attending a wedding at our dynamic earth just across the road. Also only a 15 min walk into town and 5 min taxi ride to train station

    Wallpaper peeling off one wall, room quite dark, although "fluffy robes" provided, 1 could not be used as loop for belt missing.

  • 8/10 Mike ( Junges Paar) 

    aus Newton aycliffe , GB  am  4. Juni 2007

    "We were made to feel very welcome by the friendly & efficient staff. We would recomend this hotel to friends & family who en joy walking as the hotel is some distance from the centre of Edinburgh. The D,B&B ws a very good option ,excellent quality & value for money. Would definitely stay here again!" (99489424)

    Spacious room,location,restaurant,leisure facilities

    Minibar wouldn't work .Inefficient airconditioning

  • 9/10 Anonymous ( Gruppe erwachsener Freunde) 

    am  30. Mai 2007

    "Really enjoyed our stay in the hotel, it was great value for money as we got an online deal" (99446699)

    room was lovely

  • 10/10 Norman ( Reiferes Paar) 

    aus Cleveland , GB  am  18. Mai 2007

    "all the staff were vere very friendly and helpful.the food was excellent.the location is very scenic and only ashort stroll away from the centre." (99894974)

    service.location food

  • 9/10 Anonymous ( Junges Paar) 

    am  16. Mai 2007

    "The staff in this hotel are fantastic, polite friendly and very helpful. We had a couple of problems with dinner on the second night but they were delt with perfectly and did not spoil our enjoyment. My partner and I both work in hotels and wish we could find staff this good!" (99382970)

    evening turn down service is great.

    Our room was located too close to the lift and a rather creeky door!so noise from other guests did wake us too early.

  • 9/10 Alison ( Junges Paar) 

    aus Glasgow , GB  am  11. Mai 2007

    Every single member of staff was very courteous, friendly and helpful.

    Some sort of alarm went off in our room at the time when we were meant to check out, presumably to remind us to leave. Think this was a bit rude!

  • 9/10 Paul ( Junges Paar) 

    aus Hendon , United Kingdom;GB  am  10. Mai 2007

    Staff were very friendly and helpful. Room was excellent.

    Breakfast was not part of the price of the stay and was quite expensive.

  • 10/10 Joan ( Ein Paar des gleichen Geschlechts) 

    aus Cumbernauld , GB  am  10. Mai 2007

    "Staff extremely curtious,friendly & helpful. Room was very clean & spacious & beds turned down at night. Location great for Royal Mile, Theatre & Princess Street." (99471916)

    Room was spacious & very clean.

  • 10/10 Anonymous ( Reiferes Paar) 

    am  9. Mai 2007

    "excellent hotel very clean and food in hotel excellent will definately go back on next visit to edinburgh" (99699416)

    lovely room on 6th floor very clean good location

  • 10/10 Lynda ( Andere) 

    aus Cheadle , GB  am  11. April 2007

    "We enjoyed the stay immensely, being on the 6th floor which was quite exclusive and having the facility of the pool and the butler service was quite a thrill (I really liked the champagne in the Library bit !), although because we were only there for a short time, we didn't get to use as many of the facilities as we would have liked. All the staff we came across from the ladies who turned the beds down to the reception staff, were very polite and couldn't do enough for us, they all made us feel very special." (99482286)

    Room was lovely, very clean, plenty of room and the facilities were excellent.

  • 9/10 Mary-patrica ( Gruppe erwachsener Freunde) 

    aus Leominster , UNITED KINGDOM;GB  am  17. Februar 2007

    Staff helpfulness,pleasant ambience, swimming pool.

    Lighting sysyem in the room.

  • 9/10 Kevin ( Reiferes Paar) 

    aus Cardiff , United Kingdom;GB  am  14. Februar 2007

    "Came for rugby weekend. The included lunch was very poor. Otherwise, the stay was great." (99611888)

  • 9/10 Colin ( Gruppe erwachsener Freunde) 

    aus Geddington,kettering , United Kingdom;GB  am  14. Februar 2007

    "A really good experience overall.The hotel is a reasonable distance from Princes Street,but this may not necessarily be a negative.The hotel staff are friendly,and the atmosphere relaxed.Breakfast could have lasted all day.Quiet, and comfortable bedrooms.Intend to book again for 6 Nations rugby next year,especially if the bar prices are repeated!!" (99647876)

    Very pleasant hotel.Excellent breakfast.Staff were attentive and polite,and Guiness was on offer at £1.50 a pint!!!

  • 9/10 Vicky ( Gruppe erwachsener Freunde) 

    aus York , United Kingdom;GB  am  31. Januar 2007

    "The hotel was great, the only concern we had on our stay was regarding the treatments we booked. The spa tariffs had gone up by at least £10 which we weren't informed about prior to the treatments taking place, only upon recieving the bill. This was handled very well by the Beauty Therapist who was very understanding and arranged for the difference to be removed from the bill. Overall this did not ruin our stay as it was handled very well by that one member of staff." (99070548)

    Excellent location for restaurants and bars, hotel reception staff were extremely friendly and hotel was of a high standard

  • 10/10 Anonymous ( Andere) 

    am  26. Januar 2007

    The bed was very big and comfy

  • 9/10 Samantha ( Junges Paar) 

    aus Yehtolm , United Kingdom;GB  am  23. Januar 2007

    "I was really surprised by the standard and quality of this hotel, the valet parking was excellant. The check in was slow, but I think training was in progress or a manager was trying to assist at a peak time. The hotel was spotlessly clean and the staff were a real asset to the hotel." (99489902)

    Fresh, Clean and warm - staff very pleasant and friendly. Dinner was excellant - we will be back

    Bed was very soft

  • 9/10 Beth ( Gruppe erwachsener Freunde) 

    aus Cholsey , United Kingdom;GB  am  17. Januar 2007

    Nice rooms; lovely staff; good value food.

  • 6/10 Anonymous ( Alleinreisender in geschäftlicher Angelengenheit) 

    am  20. Februar 2008

    "staff are friendly and helpfull, the bar is nice and welcomming, breakfast was yummy" (97145339)

    good room size

    the carpet in my room and also in the stairwell was stained and worn. Also there was a splash mark on the loo seat.

    0 von 1 Personen fanden diese Gästebewertung hilfreich:

  • 9/10 David ( Alleinreisender in geschäftlicher Angelengenheit) 

    aus Halifax , United Kingdom;GB  am  16. Januar 2007

    "A quality hotel with excellent facilities which deserves it's rating. The staff are very friendly and helpful and the food was very good even though I only had the Table d'hote menu.There is limited parking but managed to get a place. Location is good and quiet. Leisure club is fine with the sauna, pool and steam rooms in good condition. If in Edinburgh again would certainly consider this hotel." (99870785)

    The general friendliness of the staff and their willingness to help with any request.

  • 6/10 Simon ( Gruppe erwachsener Freunde) 

    aus Northwich , GB  am  7. Februar 2008

    "Genral feeling is that it was expensive for the accommodation offered. Items were added to the room bills which were not used (breakfast, bar tab) and had to be taken off again on departure. I certainly wouldn`t use the rapid check out system as you could end up paying for a lot of unused extras if you don`t check the bill properly." (97284085)

    Well located for our purposes

    Extras on bills

    0 von 1 Personen fanden diese Gästebewertung hilfreich:

  • 8/10 Anonymous ( Gruppe erwachsener Freunde) 

    am  7. Februar 2008

    "The service that I received was very efficient and the staff were friendly and helpful. I was not in the hotel for very long, but whilst there I was very pleased with with all aspects of the hotel and staff." (97293262)

    I was in Edinburgh for the Scotlnd v France rugby international and was only in the hotel for a short time at night, sleep and breakfast. In the time that I was there I felt that everything was very satisfactory and could not find any fault with the hotel and staff.

    0 von 1 Personen fanden diese Gästebewertung hilfreich:

  • 10/10 Aissatou ( Junges Paar) 

    aus Leeds , United Kingdom;GB  am  12. Januar 2007

    VERY CLEAN AND PROFESSIONAL ATTITUDE

  • 10/10 John ( Reiferes Paar) 

    aus Bedford , GB  am  6. Februar 2008

    "Upon arrival and throughout our stay the staff were all helpful and friendly. The facilities at the hotel were good, we used the pool and steam room one morning and that was very nice. Had I been staying longer I may have booked a treatment. I would definately want to return, if not to this specific hotel to another in your chain." (97909229)

    The rooms were very comfortable and well equipped. Whenever I needed the slightest assistance staff were more than helpfull. Even when I couldn't get the shower to run warm!

    I would have liked to had breakfast at the hotel but at £17.00 per head I thought it rather expensive. I feel this was the only draw back.

    0 von 1 Personen fanden diese Gästebewertung hilfreich:

  • 9/10 Lorraine ( Reiferes Paar) 

    aus Glasgow , United Kingdom;GB  am  11. Januar 2007

    "The hotel situation was perfect for sightseeing. The staff friendly and helpful.When we visit Edinburgh again we would consider booking this hotel" (99157421)

    The staff were discreet yet attentive.The food was a gourmet delight and served perfectly in an ambient atmosphere.

  • 7/10 Paul ( Junges Paar) 

    aus Seaham , GB  am  12. Dezember 2007

    "nice hotel shame about the weather,rainy then snowy and very windy.brrrr!who would have an anniversary in december? the hotel was nice but only a certain number of things ar free in the leisure side of things.consierge was pleasant but a bit un-needed as it made us feel a bit uneasy,life of the poor for you." (97509253)

    very nice accommodation,free upgrade to 6th floor as it was our anniversary.

    not enough time to dislike anything.

    0 von 1 Personen fanden diese Gästebewertung hilfreich:

  • 10/10 Anonymous ( Reiferes Paar) 

    am  9. Januar 2007

    "Directions to the hotel could have been clearer - fortunately we were familiar with Edinburgh. Parking was a worry but it was made simple by the hotel procedures for valet parking. Room had everything we needed. We were unaware of other guests. Meals were excellent, menu was varied, wine list was extensive. Leisure facilities were adequate. My wife heartily recommends the beauty treatment offer. Hotel location was convenient for central Edinburgh." (99162642)

    Clean, comfortable, relaxing, quiet.

    Problems with pool pump meant that the water temperature took the breathe away!

  • 8/10 Duncan ( Alleinreisender in geschäftlicher Angelengenheit) 

    aus Northampton , GB  am  4. Dezember 2007

    "This a good hotel and I would recomend it, and may well stay again myself in the future." (97870919)

    The hotel is nice and clean through out and the use of the gym / health suite is great.

    The room rate is high considering breakfast is not included in that rate. I have stayed here previously at a lower rate with Breakfast included. This reduced the value for money that I felt Iwas getting.

    0 von 1 Personen fanden diese Gästebewertung hilfreich:

  • 9/10 Louise ( Junges Paar) 

    aus Swords , Ireland;IE  am  4. Januar 2007

    "Great place, convenient location - even has a shop nearby & pizza express next door if you don't fancy the 10 min walk uptown, or the reataurant in the hotel. V clean, nice staff - recommended" (99278544)

    Clean, spacious, close to city, leisure facilities

    V expensive New Year's Eve rate - almost 3 times normal rate

  • 9/10 Anonymous ( Junges Paar) 

    am  4. Januar 2007

    Room was spacious, with good facilities. Swimming Pool & Sauna were top class.

    Price of restaurant & bar

  • 8/10 Anonymous ( Junges Paar) 

    am  4. Januar 2007

    "This hotel was very nice and in a very good loctaion for our stay. Overall I was pleased." (99321564)

    Very comfortable and clean. Breakfast very nice and quick. Generally a very nice hotel.

    Some things in the room were not as stated.

  • 10/10 Anonymous ( Reiferes Paar) 

    am  14. November 2007

    "More detail on special offer(s) i.e. B & B c/w evening meals. Prior to checking internet, called reception and prices quoted were considerably more exspensive. Overall we had a pleasant & comfortable VFM stay - thank you." (97044979)

    Location. Food. Overall quality - comfort

    T.V. in room. Plasma would have been more suitable. Exspensive drinks. Parking charge.

    0 von 1 Personen fanden diese Gästebewertung hilfreich:

  • 9/10 Anonymous ( Reiferes Paar) 

    am  4. Dezember 2006

    "Bearing in mind the very reasonable price, this hotel (and the staff) exceeded our expectations." (99915656)

    Above average room size, very clean. Staff were firendly and efficient.

    Took a long time to get any hot water in the shower!

  • 8/10 Fatima ( Reiferes Paar) 

    aus Amman , JO  am  8. Oktober 2007

    "the hotel has a good location, walking distance from the center of the city, a few needed services were close and available. all requested assistance was taken care off, such as Taxis and travel tours were easily summoned by staff." (97088878)

    it was homely, placed in a quiet area, staff were hospitable,pleasant and helpfull.

    the TV channels in the rooms were very limmited to few local channels, additional international satellite News and commedy show channels would have been informative and delightful, I would also appreciate an internet connection in the room. also adding a simple breakfast to the rate of room would have been appropriate, a sum of fifteen pound sterling breakfast rate was very expensive.

    0 von 1 Personen fanden diese Gästebewertung hilfreich:

  • 9/10 Peter ( Junges Paar) 

    aus York , United Kingdom;GB  am  23. November 2006

    "Generally very good, an unpretentious and very comfortable hotel in an excellent location, with helpful and efficient staff." (99726805)

    Large and well-furnished rooms, well-maintained public spaces, polite and efficient staff.

    Complimentary bathrobes had clearly been used by heavy smokers and had a very unpleasant smell of smoke to them. A late night fire alarm was a minor irritant but was handled efficiently and undramatically.

  • 10/10 Christine ( Andere) 

    aus Belleville , CA  am  2. August 2007

    It was a great hotel, very clean with excellent customer service. A fantastic deal for the price!

    0 von 1 Personen fanden diese Gästebewertung hilfreich:

  • 9/10 Anonymous ( Gruppe erwachsener Freunde) 

    am  16. November 2006

    "Excellent value if there is a special offer - £89 for a twin room was really good. Great location, helpful staff, good facilities and lovely rooms and dinner for £20 was good, drinks and breakfast expensive..but probably the norm for a 4* hotel. Nice pool and sauna." (99754300)

    The location was good, the rooms were lovely, the service was great.

    The price of drinks in the bar was very high. The cost of continental breakfast was too high.

  • 10/10 Anonymous ( Reiferes Paar) 

    am  26. Juli 2007

    "We had a very relaxing stay at the Holyrood Hotel. It was a bonus to have a free upgrade to a junior suite. Staff were very helpful and look after guests well. I would use this hotel again for a weekend break in the city." (97218848)

    I particularly liked the location of this hotel. It is located in a quiet, but very convenient area of Edinburgh.

    I was a bit disappointed with the swimming pool, which in my opinion could do with a bit of a face lift.

    0 von 1 Personen fanden diese Gästebewertung hilfreich:

  • 9/10 Anonymous ( Junges Paar) 

    am  8. November 2006

    "a very enjoyable relaxing break to which my husbond and i needed. thankyou." (99373982)

    the rooms and spa were very clean and relaxing

    hair drier did not work, some items such as shower cap were not replaced dailey

  • 5/10 Stephen ( Reiferes Paar) 

    aus Leyland , GB  am  17. Juli 2007

    "Please see the complaints above. For the amount of money spent, I do not feel I got a fair deal." (97192316)

    The staff were very helpful and friendly, especially the new girl on reception. Also the young man who helped me with my luggage.

    1. I do not like to have to pay extra for internet access when the room costs so much. 2. Cheap TV with only 5 channels and lousy picture. 3. Dirty bathroom floor, which was not cleaned throughout our stay. 4. Did not receive a newspaper on any of the mornings, even though I notified reception. 5. The breakfast was far too expensive, especially when all that was ordered was bacon and eggs, which cost £15.75 - terrible.

    0 von 1 Personen fanden diese Gästebewertung hilfreich:

  • 10/10 Will ( Ein Paar des gleichen Geschlechts) 

    aus Selkirk , United Kingdom;GB  am  2. November 2006

    "A very good hotel in a nice location that have all you need for business and pleasure." (99474962)

    Nice, spacious rooms, mini bar - you don't have to phone room service for a drink - the executive lounge is nice and relaxing, the restaurant is very good and the service is excellent.

  • 9/10 Peter ( Familie mit älteren Kindern) 

    aus Sevenoaks , United Kingdom;GB  am  31. Oktober 2006

    "Generally this was easily the best of the three similar grade (and price) hotels we stayed at on this trip. The only thing letting it down was the congestion in the restaurant for breakfast where the system perhaps needs to be looked at. That said, the staff were extremely apologetic and tried to make things easier (unlike our experience at a subsequent hotel.)" (99396563)

    All of the staff were extremely friendly and well trained and really made us welcome

    The room (701) was very noisy due to the air conditioning fan(?) in the carpark. View was a bit sordid.

  • 9/10 Anonymous ( Gruppe erwachsener Freunde) 

    am  28. Oktober 2006

    "Great location just off Royal Mile, so quiet at night. Great pool facilities with sauna and steam room. Room very comfortable with a great view of scottish parliament building. staff very helpful and pleasant. Could be problem if woman walking alone at night- quite dark passageways to get to Royal Mile." (99015870)

    very comfortable room and excellent pool/sauna/steam room

  • 8/10 Gareth ( Junges Paar) 

    aus Stoke on trent , United Kingdom;GB  am  27. Oktober 2006

    "I found out alot about the hotel on the web site and found no nasty hidden supprises, which is good, and the hotel and the description of the area was spot on." (99870684)

    We enjoyed the hotel alot, staff were very frendly and helpful. very clean and in a good quiet location but walking distance to all night life and shops.

    It was pretty expensive to stay in the hotel for a drink and mini bar was really really over priced.The car park was expensive seems as it is below the hotal and cost no more for the hotel as in extra land to occupy.

  • 8/10 Anonymous ( Reiferes Paar) 

    am  26. Oktober 2006

    "good hotel,friendly staff, good location." (99278307)

    friendly staff overall quality of hotel

    fifteen pounds per night parking. fifteen pounds for a breakfast seems a bit high.

  • 8/10 Suzanne ( Junges Paar) 

    aus Newcastle upon tyne , United Kingdom;GB  am  25. Oktober 2006

    The hotel was in an ideal location and very friendly with a relaxed atmosphere, particularly liked the fluffy dressing gowns

    Couldn't get the shower to go on hot so had to have a cold shower.

  • 8/10 Ruth ( Einzelreisender) 

    aus Inverness , United Kingdom;GB  am  23. Oktober 2006

    Spacious room, leisure facilities...good opening hours

    Nothing of any importance

Die Ansichten die hier geäussert wurden sind die persönlichen Meinungen der Gäste und vertreten daher nicht durchaus die Ansichten von Active Hotels, Active Reservations oder unserer Verteilungspartner. (Über unsere Hotelbewertungen).

hotel map

Hotels in der Nähe.