Language: English | Français | Español | Deutsch | Italiano | Nederlands | Polski | Portuguese | Swedish | Norwegian | Danish
4 star

Macdonald Marine Hotel & Spa, North Berwick

18 Cromwell Road, North Berwick, EH39 4LZ
Hotel Homepage | Guest Reviews | How to Book & Cancel | Security & Privacy | Late Availability

Guest Reviews

Summary of Guest Ratings

Check-in process 4.0 / 5 4.0 / 5
Working order of facilities / equipment 4.2 / 5 4.2 / 5
Overall value for money 3.7 / 5 3.7 / 5
Performance of staff 4.2 / 5 4.2 / 5
Your room 4.3 / 5 4.3 / 5
Overall experience 4.1 / 5 4.1 / 5
Order and cleanliness of the hotel 4.5 / 5 4.5 / 5
Guest Rating 4.1 / 5 4.1 / 5

How to book this hotel or view prices

calendar
Night(s) Room(s)

Guest Reviews

2.6 / 5 2.6 / 5 Anonymous on 30/06/2008 (Young couple)

Fantastic location with great views. Hotel very clean and spa services were excellent.

Noisy banging at 3am each night, woken up with alarm calls that were not ordered and staff entering room at night without knocking. 2nd night price hiked up to

Overall: Poor value for money considering how much the room rate was.  (97059150)

4.3 / 5 4.3 / 5 marlene [edinburgh, GB] on 02/03/2008 (Mature couple)

i enjoyed the facilities that were available

waiting time on check in and out,drinks expensive

Overall: i enjoyed the stay i had apart from a few things, and had 2 eat out of the hotel which i didn,t like,food not nice  (97566085)

4.4 / 5 4.4 / 5 Tim [ilkley, GB] on 08/02/2008 (Other)

staff attitude superb, clean, views, parking.

Restaurant a bit expensive but very good. toilet in room 216 too near wall!, needs moving 6 Spa facilities out of bounds to under 16's.

Overall: Pleased with overall experiance.TV did not work properly but soon sorted by extremely helpful staff. Nice blend of old and new building and interiors. Good parking. Spa facilities out of bounds to under 16's which is ok if you are adults wanting a rest but i had my 5 and 12 year old children with me!This is the first hotel we have been to which has this policy.  (97396896)

4.6 / 5 4.6 / 5 Anonymous on 07/12/2007 (Mature couple)

 (97036080)

4.6 / 5 4.6 / 5 Anonymous on 29/11/2007 (Mature couple)

A period building yet with a multi million pound contemporary makeover - beautiful!

nothing - would have loved a sea view!

Overall: The sea view. A review of the restuarant which was excellent and how busy the spa gets on a monday morning!  (97572920)

4.1 / 5 4.1 / 5 Anonymous on 14/11/2007 (Group of adult friends)

Large bedroom Breakfast good Great location

Foyer very dull & unwelcoming Some bedrooms tired

Overall: Really nice but expensive. not worth the money. Cold blustery weather & lit fires in foyer etc would have been a nice touch. Lighting in public areas harsh & not relaxing  (97119922)

Why do we publish ratings from Active Hotels?

Our rating system is designed to give you the confidence to find and book the hotel that best suits your needs. We've worked hard to create a fair and impartial process to collect our ratings so you can always be assured of a great hotel experience.

How do I add a rating?

Unlike other sites that offer ratings, our rating process is by invitation only. This ensures that 100% of the ratings you see on our site come from guests that have booked online with us and stayed at the hotel in question.

All our ratings are created by guests who have booked through Active Hotels (or its sister sites) and completed their stay over the last year. We don't edit, alter or adjust the ratings so you can be sure of unbiased opinions.

How do you manage to collect so many ratings?

48 hours after departure from your accommodation booked through Active Hotels or any of our sister sites, you may be invited to complete a guest review questionnaire. This means that, for most hotels, we're able to post more than 1 guest rating every single week. We currently display over 70,000 ratings and we add hundreds of scores from real guests every day.